A philosophical framework for teaching, education, and research

Share what we know. Learn it together. Keep the thinking human.

We now have more power to generate, connect, and share ideas than at any point in history. Education should use that power openly. That means less guarding of "my idea" and more collaboration: among specialists across fields, across institutions, across generations, and with the next generation of students as our research partners from the start.

The framework

Three elements

Everything here rests on these three elements. Each one shows up across the framework, and in the network of people, organizations, and hubs it connects.

Self-knowledge

Know how you learn, what you believe, and where your gaps are.

“Know thyself” was carved at the temple of Apollo at Delphi, and Socrates made it the starting point of philosophy.

Praxis

Theory and action together: learn by doing real work, then reflect on it.

Aristotle set praxis, thoughtful action, beside theory. Paulo Freire defined it as reflection and action upon the world in order to transform it.

Universality

Knowledge open to everyone, and fields connected into a whole.

The word university comes from the Latin universitas: the whole community of teachers and scholars.

Where this comes from

Back to the Lyceum

This whole endeavor is inspired by something very old. For the ancient Greeks, there was no wall between geology, biology, astronomy, and ethics. It was all natural philosophy: one long conversation about how the world works and how we should live in it.

Get back to the basics: seminar, symposium, and mentorship.

Read more: the Lyceum, then and now

Aristotle's Lyceum ran on conversation, often while walking its covered walkways, and on close mentorship. Its members gathered observations of animals, plants, and places and pooled what they found. Out of that shared work, Aristotle's student and successor Theophrastus wrote one of the first systematic studies of plants.

The tools have changed. Open data, AI, and linked hubs can do what the Lyceum's library and collections did, at a scale the Greeks never imagined. What's worth recovering is the spirit: knowledge as a shared conversation across fields, and learning done together, in person, alongside someone who knows more than you and cares that you learn it.

In short

The commitments

Instead of paywallsEvery article free to read, funded publicly
Instead of guarded syllabiLectures, reading lists, and course designs shared openly
Instead of silosHubs that aggregate fields without centralizing them
Instead of rivalryCooperation across labs, fields, and generations
Instead of a scattered first yearA shared first semester: one survey course in ethics and pedagogy, practical arts taught as disciplines, and daily wellness
Instead of random electivesEarly research, driven by curiosity, with rotating mentors
Instead of picking a major blindA foundation year of work, service, and exposure
Instead of passive lecturesBuildings full of seminars, symposia, and talks
Instead of lowered barsCompetency-based entry, handwritten or oral, in your own words
Instead of last year's assignmentFresh assessments every year, shared across universities
Instead of busywork homeworkStudents critiquing and correcting AI-drafted hub content
Instead of one track for allAdvancing students on the strengths they arrive with
Instead of losing what they knowElders recorded, consulted, and credited
↑ Back to the outlinePart 1 of 5

Open knowledge

Free articles and courses, cooperation over competition, and hubs that link the fields.

Open by default

Knowledge should be free to everyone who wants it

Knowledge that could improve people's lives or the health of the environment should be shared as soon as possible. Publishing costs money, and public budgets should cover it, so that any interested person can read any article or book they'd like, the same way we fund roads and libraries.

Open courses, too

Reading lists and lecture subjects shouldn't be proprietary either. If you have a good idea for a course, you lecture it well, and your students learn from it, share it with everybody. MIT OpenCourseWare and Harvard's free online courses already do this. They put their best teaching right out there, and it only adds to their reputation.

Sharing the content doesn't weaken rigor. Lectures, readings, and syllabi can be open to all, while the assignments and exams stay fresh every year.

The spirit of it

Cooperate and collaborate, not compete and eliminate.

Why wouldn't that be possible?

Too much of academic life runs on scarcity: guarding data, racing to publish, competing for the same grants. The tools we have now reward the opposite: ideas multiply when they're shared, and they stall when they're kept to ourselves.

Geology lab Ecology lab Anthropology lab A, B, C = which university the lab belongs to
Unified, not centralized

Knowledge hubs, linked like a living encyclopedia

Centralizing knowledge and unifying it are different things. Centralizing puts everything in one place under one owner. Unifying leaves knowledge with the experts who make and understand it, and connects it so it reads as a whole.

Read more: how hubs work

Experts keep doing their own work and keep their own data, but they link their databases, visualizations, and explanations into public hubs. Each hub connects to the neighboring fields it touches, to the labs doing the research, and to the educators explaining it.

Finding out that something exists is half the fun, and also half the battle. It can take years to discover who works on a question you care about. A drawn link between two fields costs almost nothing, and could start a conversation years sooner.

Centralized

All knowledge flows into one place. One gatekeeper decides what's kept, who sees it, and what it costs. If the center fails or closes its doors, everything goes with it.

Unified

Knowledge stays with the people who make it. Shared links and standards connect it into one map, and anyone can follow the connections. No single owner, and no single point of failure.

Hub Core layer of the hub Bordering field

Example hub: Drifting Through Deep Time ↗. Select any node to see what it adds, who would contribute, and a question a student could start with.

Where this hub fits

Excellent tools for deep time already exist, but each covers one layer or one audience. Drifting Through Deep Time brings the layers together around one question, links outward to the people doing the work, and is built so students can check and improve it.

Ancient Earth globe

Shows where your town sat as continents moved over 750 million years. One layer: geography.

GPlates

Open-source plate reconstruction software. Powerful, but built for researchers.

Neotoma

Open, community-curated fossil pollen and paleoecology data. Rich data, not a guided story.

ChronoZoom and Big History

Zoom from the Big Bang to today. Strong on time, lighter on place and on who is researching what.

Drifting Through Deep TimeExplore it, with a guided tour ↗

Continents, vegetation, climate, and human migration layered in one view. Linked to labs, educators, and neighboring fields. Reviewed and improved by students. And a template anyone can copy to build a hub for their own field.

A template, not just a website

The hub's most transferable value is its pattern. It works as a teaching tool, and it also works as a style template for connecting digitally with people on similar projects. Sociologists Susan Leigh Star and James Griesemer called objects like this boundary objects: things that different communities can each use in their own way, while still holding them in common. Their example was a natural history museum where amateurs and professionals built a shared collection.

Anyone can make a hub. The recipe is simple:

  1. A core question people actually care about.
  2. Layers from the fields that help answer it.
  3. Links outward to bordering fields, labs, educators, and elders.
  4. A review loop where students check and improve the content, with credit.
  5. An open license so others can copy the pattern for their own field.
Open, with care: how hubs are moderated

Hubs are public and meant to be safe for all viewers, from schoolchildren to elders. Every contribution is reviewed before it appears. Where a subject is difficult by nature, it is presented with care, context, and respect for the people reading it.

↑ Back to the outlinePart 2 of 5

Learning and research

Learning that rewards and challenges, students improving AI-drafted knowledge, figures before chapters, the lab as a mentoring network, and elders on the record.

Zone of proximal development

Rewarding, challenging, and worth doing

Students should get right into doing what rewards them and also challenges them. Learning should feel worth doing, not wear students down. Psychologist Lev Vygotsky called the space between what a learner can do alone and what they can do with help the zone of proximal development. Work there stretches students without losing them.

Mentors keep the match right, raising the challenge as skill grows. The chart below is similar to psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi's model of challenge and skill: too easy and we get bored, too hard and we get anxious. Try it below.

Anxiety Boredom Zone of proximal development Skill → Challenge →
Homework that matters

AI drafts. Students correct. Everyone learns.

When experts use AI to build hubs, the result is mostly right, but not entirely. Here, AI's failings make for good learning: students take in the content from what's right, and build critical thinking by finding and fixing what isn't.

The assignment is simple: AI made this, now make it better. Students check each claim against the scholarly literature, correct and cite what they find, and add their own insight. Then they present the changes they've made to classmates and the hub's working group, along with projects they've added to the hub. They can work alone or in groups, in the afternoons and evenings after the day's work.

Read more: an example from plant phylogenies

Take a module for exploring plant phylogenies, where patterns in plant evolution become visible that an entering undergraduate would rarely find alone. There are far too many plants for one expert to proofread every species entry, and much of the life-history information comes from Wikipedia. That's excellent work for a young student.

Step 1AI drafts the entry

From Wikipedia and other open sources, inside the hub.

Step 2Read it once

Learn the material, which is mostly right.

Step 3Check the literature

Learn to find and read scholarly sources.

Step 4Add your flourish

Correct, cite, and improve the entry.

Step 5Present your work

Share your changes, and any projects you've added, with classmates and the hub's working group. Accepted work goes into the hub, credited to you.

Try it: review an AI-drafted entry

Below is the kind of entry a student might get as their assignment. Decide whether each claim is accurate, wrong, or needs a source, then see what a careful reviewer would find.

Ginkgo bilobaExample AI draft · for student review

Figures before chapters

See the whole, then the detail

AI makes it easy to turn complex subject matter into figures: maps, trees, timelines, and networks that anyone can explore. People take in and remember a good figure far better than the same idea spread across chapters of text. Psychologists call this the picture superiority effect, and learners do best with words and pictures together.

The goal is to condense a concept to its most succinct expression, while keeping the granular detail close at hand: a figure you can open layer by layer, down to the original sources.

The same rule applies as for text: a figure built with AI is a draft, and students check it against the sources. Drifting Through Deep Time ↗ puts 540 million years of continents, plants, and people into one globe and one tree.

Read more: the research behind it

Pictures are remembered better than words (Nelson, Reed & Walling 1976). Information held both as words and as images is easier to recall than either alone (Paivio's dual coding theory, 1971). People learn more deeply from words with pictures than from words alone (Mayer, Multimedia Learning, 2009).

CondenseOne figure for the whole idea

The pattern is seen at a glance, before any detail.

OpenLayers on demand

Turn on what you need, zoom into what you're curious about.

TraceEvery mark to its source

Each point links back to the study or dataset behind it.

CheckStudents verify

Figures made with AI get the same scrutiny as text.

Research comes first, not last

The lab as a mentoring network

Research shouldn't wait until a student's final years. It should start early and follow their interests. Students should rotate through several specialists to discover what they love doing, instead of filling their schedule with electives they aren't sure they'll use.

Think network, not hierarchy. Mentoring runs in many directions, and the roles shade into one another as a gradient rather than stacking as rungs. PhD students mentor master's students and undergraduates alike. Everyone can host visitors, though master's students and advanced undergraduates field most of the visiting public, and undergraduates take the bulk of welcoming prospective students.

Everyone in the lab is both learning and teaching. And because AI is still wrong some of the time, there is always meaningful work to do: checking, sourcing, testing, and making sense of things.

Occasional Regular Main role Direction help and knowledge flow

Select anyone to see what they give and what they get. Help rarely flows equally both ways: a professor gives a PhD student far more than the reverse, but the PhD student still helps.

Before it's lost

Get our elders on the record

Senior scholars and practitioners carry a view of the world that took a lifetime to build. Experts should compile what they know while they still can. We should interview them about what they value, how they see their fields, and the ideas they never got to study. Then we can invite them to review the hubs and modules and tell us whether they look right.

Their unfinished questions become a template for the next generation's research.

↑ Back to the outlinePart 3 of 5

Pathways

A foundation year, a shared first semester, and halls full of conversation.

A new front door

A foundation year before anyone has to choose a major

Imagine a publicly subsidized season, or a whole year, of work and service. Young people live together at low cost, grow food, cook, and care for animals. They spend their days alongside students, graduate students, and professors. They learn practical and social skills many people never got growing up, and they see up close what different kinds of work look like.

Read more: how the year works, and who it fits

The work offsets the cost. Scheduled hours of weeding, cooking, and butchering, with the meat science program in on it, run a farm-to-cafeteria operation that feeds the campus. In the first two semesters, a student may take one class per term if they want. Graduate students teach those classes, which helps fund their own research. In their off time, students can join study groups and work through the basics with good online modules. Choosing to do that is a good sign of the drive they'll need later.

The year also fits the person. Someone who grew up knowing plants or birds from their family shouldn't wait in line. Move them quickly into hands-on work, like bird banding, so a strength they arrived with becomes a skill. Everyone has their own strengths, and college should be shaped around them.

Nobody has to bet four years on a guess. Pick a path below to see how it might play out.

GrowVegetables, flowers, and orchards, on whatever the growing season allows
MakeCooking, baking bread, butchery, and the culinary arts. Everyone who works in the kitchen earns a food safety certification
TendCaring for animals and land
ServeRunning the farm-to-cafeteria kitchen that feeds campus
LearnUp to one class a term during the first two semesters, taught by grad students
StudyParticipate in study groups of interest during off hours
MeetRotating time with specialists, labs, and students
For every undergraduate

Semester one: learn to teach, think, and tend

Every undergraduate takes one combined survey course in ethics and pedagogy, informed by modern thinking in philosophy of mind and phenomenology. Pedagogy is at its heart, because in this system everyone teaches: undergraduates host visitors, mentor newer students, and explain their work in seminars.

Life skills are taught as real disciplines with real experts. That means culinary arts rather than just cooking, gardening informed by horticulture, livestock farming informed by rangeland management, and carpentry, metalworking, and auto maintenance in a shared makerspace and shop. Wellness, from exercise and yoga to nutrition, is part of every day.

MorningsGarden and pasture
AfternoonsSeminars
Late afternoonsWellness: exercise, yoga, nutrition
EveningsStudy groups
Teach and think
One survey course, taken by everyoneEthics and Pedagogy

Informed by modern thinking in philosophy of mind and phenomenology.

Tend
What the buildings are for

Fill the halls with conversation

This is the Lyceum part. If explanations can live in interactive maps, videos, and hubs, then a lecture hall doesn't need to hold a hundred half-asleep students hearing what they could have read. Some lecture courses will always make sense. But the rooms could also host symposia, seminars, and talks all day long.

Open to the public, but at what cost?

The seminars, symposia, and talks that fill these buildings could be open to anyone, and recorded for the hubs. That raises an open question: should members of the public pay a small fee to attend, and should students? Each option has trade-offs.

↑ Back to the outlinePart 4 of 5

Standards and habits

Real standards in your own words, and habits for an examined life.

Rigor

Real standards, measured against the work

Openness doesn't mean anything goes. To restore the value of a degree, you should have to really try to get in. Entry is a handwritten short-answer and essay exam, or an oral exam, on 100-level material the student has studied hard. Admission is measured against a standard of work, not against other applicants. Fall short and you can try again, or find a path that suits you better. Once you're in, you get support along the way, so you don't need constant rescuing later.

We can't keep turning out AI-substituted students. If you can't put an idea in your own words, you haven't learned it yet.

Students should arrive able to write. AI belongs in the work, for checking, exploring, and visualizing, but it can't replace the person doing the thinking.

Why wouldn't they cheat?

Right now the same assignment comes back every year. The answers are already on homework-help sites and flashcard decks, and AI produces the rest in seconds. Teachers end up knowing a student cheated but unable to prove it, sitting through honor-code hearings, and being lied to by students who know they'll get away with it. When a system rewards cheating and rarely catches it, cheating is the rational choice. The answer is better design, not more policing.

Course content can carry over from year to year. Assignments shouldn't. No assignment should be identical to last year's. Universities can share that load: professors across institutions contributing to a shared, secure bank of fresh questions, and building learning and quiz modules that actually teach, instead of rehashing the basics.

↑ Back to the outlinePart 5 of 5

Context

Who's already doing this, the books behind it, and further reading.

Already happening

None of this has to be invented from scratch

Pieces of this vision already exist, scattered across field stations, databases, colleges, and courses. The work ahead is to connect them and make them the norm rather than the exception.

Early researchRocky Mountain Biological Laboratory

A high-mountain field station in Gothic, Colorado, where scientists from many universities share one valley each summer. Undergraduates design independent projects with a scientist mentor and present them at an end-of-summer symposium.

Visit site ↗
Shared hubsNCEAS, UC Santa Barbara

The National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis has supported hundreds of working groups that bring researchers from different fields and countries together, and it asks that their data be archived in open repositories.

Visit site ↗
Shared hubsNeotoma Paleoecology Database

A free, community-curated database of fossil pollen and other paleoecological records. Regional groups such as the European, North American, and Latin American pollen databases each steward their own data: aggregated, not centralized.

Visit site ↗
Early researchSEA-PHAGES

A two-semester course for first-year students, run by HHMI and the University of Pittsburgh at more than 150 colleges. Students dig up soil, discover new viruses, and submit real data, and some become published authors.

Visit site ↗
Students improving knowledgeWiki Education

College instructors assign students to improve Wikipedia articles instead of writing papers nobody reads. Students learn to find credible sources, and the public gets better articles.

Visit site ↗
Work and a foundation yearDeep Springs College

A two-year college on a cattle ranch and alfalfa farm in California. Students work at least 20 hours a week on the ranch, in the kitchen, and around campus, and help govern the college.

Visit site ↗
Work and a foundation yearBerea College and the work colleges

Berea, in Kentucky, is one of a small group of federally recognized work colleges, where every student works as part of their education. Berea charges no tuition.

Visit site ↗
Work and a foundation yearNordic folk high schools

One-year residential schools, common in Norway and Denmark since 1844, with no exams or grades. Many young people attend one as a gap year between secondary school and university.

Visit site ↗
Open coursesMIT OpenCourseWare

MIT has published materials from thousands of its courses, including lecture notes, reading lists, and exams, free for anyone to use.

Visit site ↗
A working corpus

Books for putting this into practice

A starting library, grouped by element. Each entry has a short synopsis and a note on how it helps turn the framework into practice. Books marked “Start here” are the most practical.

Self-knowledge · 4th century BCE · GreekNicomachean EthicsAristotle

The good life is an activity guided by virtue. Virtues of character become ours through practice, the way one becomes a builder by building, and practical wisdom judges what to do in each situation.

Toward activationCharacter is built by repeated action, so the framework has to give students real, repeated practice, not just rules.

Self-knowledge · c. 65 CE · LatinLetters on EthicsSeneca

More than a hundred letters of practical advice to a younger friend, on time, hardship, friendship, and becoming better each day.

Toward activationA model of mentorship at a distance, and of philosophy as a daily practice rather than a theory.

Self-knowledge · 1941 · EnglishEscape from FreedomErich Fromm

Freedom from old constraints can feel like a burden. People escape it through submission or conformity unless they also gain freedom to act: spontaneous, productive work of their own.

Toward activationAutonomy needs support. Pair freedom with the skills and the community that make it bearable.

Self-knowledge · 1956 · EnglishThe Art of LovingErich Fromm

Love is an art, and mastering any art takes discipline, concentration, patience, and supreme concern for it.

Toward activationThe same four conditions describe mastering any discipline. They underpin “Freedom takes discipline.”

Self-knowledge · 1976 · German and EnglishTo Have or To Be?Erich Fromm

Two modes of existence: having, which possesses and consumes, and being, which engages and grows. Students in the having mode store lecture notes; in the being mode they think along and respond.

Toward activationNames what goes wrong with AI-substituted work: possessing an answer is not the same as having thought it.

Self-knowledge · 1994 · EnglishTeaching to Transgressbell hooks

Engaged pedagogy: teaching as a practice of freedom, where teachers bring their whole selves and students' voices count. Draws on Freire and Thich Nhat Hanh.

Toward activationHow seminars should feel: participatory, mutual, and excited about ideas.

Start here for practicePraxis · 1938 · EnglishExperience and EducationJohn Dewey

Not every experience educates. Good experiences connect to what came before and lead to further growth. Dewey criticizes both rigid traditional schooling and structureless progressive schooling.

Toward activationA design test for the foundation year and every assignment: does this experience lead somewhere?

Praxis · 1916 · EnglishDemocracy and EducationJohn Dewey

Education as the continual reshaping of experience, and schools as small democratic communities where students learn by taking part in shared work and inquiry.

Toward activationThe philosophical root of the foundation year and the lab network: learning through shared, meaningful work.

Praxis · 1962 · EnglishThe Excitement of ScienceJohn R. Platt

Essays by a biophysicist on the thrill of discovery and on how scientists can think boldly, creatively, and well.

Toward activationHelps students experience research as rewarding and worth doing, from their first semester.

Praxis · 1968 · PortuguesePedagogy of the OppressedPaulo Freire

Rejects the “banking” model of depositing facts into students in favor of dialogue and problem-posing, where teachers and students investigate together.

Toward activationTurns homework into shared investigation, as in correcting AI-drafted entries.

Start here for practicePraxis · 1990 · EnglishWe Make the Road by WalkingMyles Horton and Paulo Freire

A recorded conversation between two lifelong educators about how they actually ran their programs, from Highlander in Tennessee to adult literacy in Brazil.

Toward activationThe most practical guide here to starting from people's own experience and building programs that last.

Praxis · 1991 · EnglishSituated LearningJean Lave and Etienne Wenger

Newcomers learn by taking part in a community of practice, moving from simple tasks at the edges toward full participation.

Toward activationThe theory behind the lab as a mentoring network.

Start here for practicePraxis · 2002 · EnglishCultivating Communities of PracticeEtienne Wenger, Richard McDermott, and William Snyder

A practical guide to starting and sustaining communities of practice, with principles such as designing for evolution, inviting different levels of participation, and creating a rhythm.

Toward activationStep-by-step help for building the hubs and working groups.

Praxis · 1974 · EnglishZen and the Art of Motorcycle MaintenanceRobert M. Pirsig

A father and son's motorcycle journey becomes an inquiry into Quality: caring about what you do, and joining hands-on and theoretical understanding. Recounts an experiment with withholding grades.

Toward activationCare and craft as the heart of learning, and assessment built on understanding rather than grades.

Praxis · 2009 · EnglishShop Class as SoulcraftMatthew B. Crawford

Manual work is mentally demanding and gives a real sense of agency. Crawford argues against treating the trades as lesser than office work.

Toward activationThe case for teaching practical arts as real disciplines.

Praxis · 2008 · EnglishThe CraftsmanRichard Sennett

The desire to do a job well for its own sake, and how skill grows through practice and the conversation between hand and head.

Toward activationShows that kitchen, garden, and lab share one craft ethic.

Praxis · 1990 · EnglishFlowMihaly Csikszentmihalyi

Optimal experience comes when challenge matches skill. Too easy brings boredom, too hard brings anxiety.

Toward activationLearning that rewards, challenges, and feels worth doing.

Start here for practicePraxis · 2014 · EnglishMake It StickPeter Brown, Henry Roediger, and Mark McDaniel

The science of learning for a general reader: retrieval practice, spacing, and mixing topics work, and rereading creates an illusion of mastery.

Toward activationThe evidence behind the conscious learning habits.

Start here for practicePraxis · 2004 · EnglishWhat the Best College Teachers DoKen Bain

A study of exceptional teachers. They build environments around intriguing questions, trust students, and expect much of them.

Toward activationA model for seminars, mentors, and the pedagogy course.

Praxis · 2013 · EnglishBraiding SweetgrassRobin Wall Kimmerer

A botanist and member of the Potawatomi Nation braids Indigenous knowledge and science, centered on gratitude and reciprocity with the land.

Toward activationGrounds the garden, the pasture, and getting elders on the record.

Universality · 1971 · EnglishDeschooling SocietyIvan Illich

Argues that schools confuse process with substance, and proposes learning webs: directories of resources, skill exchanges, peer matching, and educators anyone can reach.

Toward activationA blueprint for the hubs and the network.

Start here for practiceUniversality · 1990 · EnglishGoverning the CommonsElinor Ostrom

Communities can manage shared resources without state control or privatization, using design principles such as clear boundaries, local rule-making, monitoring, graduated sanctions, and ways to resolve conflict.

Toward activationGovernance for the network: how to vet contributions and keep it safe without becoming a company or a bureaucracy.

Universality · 2007 · EnglishUnderstanding Knowledge as a CommonsCharlotte Hess and Elinor Ostrom, eds.

Applies commons thinking to knowledge, from libraries to open access and digital archives.

Toward activationFrames hubs and open information as a commons to be stewarded together.

Universality · 2012 · EnglishReinventing DiscoveryMichael Nielsen

How open, networked collaboration, from the Polymath Project to citizen science, can speed up discovery.

Toward activationEvidence that open networks of experts actually work.

Universality · 2015 · EnglishThe Invention of NatureAndrea Wulf

A biography of Alexander von Humboldt, who saw nature as one web of life linking plants, climate, geology, and people.

Toward activationA model for hubs like Drifting Through Deep Time that connect fields.

Universality · 1958 · EnglishThe Human ConditionHannah Arendt

Distinguishes labor, work, and action, and argues that people show who they are by acting and speaking together in a shared, public world.

Toward activationA case for seminars, symposia, and open forums as places where people act together, not only receive instruction.

Further reading

The conversation this joins

These ideas build on a long line of thinking about how people learn, how knowledge is shared, and how research communities work.

Visions close to this one
  • Ivan Illich, Deschooling Society (1971), on “learning webs” that connect learners with people and resources
  • Michael Nielsen, Reinventing Discovery: The New Era of Networked Science (2012)
  • Charlotte Hess and Elinor Ostrom, eds., Understanding Knowledge as a Commons (2007)
  • Boyer Commission, Reinventing Undergraduate Education: A Blueprint for America's Research Universities (1998)
Pedagogy
  • Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger, Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation (1991)
  • John Dewey, Democracy and Education (1916) and Experience and Education (1938)
  • Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968)
  • Lev Vygotsky, Mind in Society (1978), on the zone of proximal development
  • David Kolb, Experiential Learning (1984)
  • Benjamin Bloom, “The 2 Sigma Problem,” Educational Researcher (1984)
  • Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke, “Test-Enhanced Learning,” Psychological Science (2006)
  • bell hooks, Teaching to Transgress (1994)
Open knowledge
  • Budapest Open Access Initiative (2002) and Plan S (2018)
  • U.S. Office of Science and Technology Policy, public access memo (2022)
  • Peter Suber, Open Access (2012)
  • UNESCO, Recommendation on Open Educational Resources (2019)
  • Mark Wilkinson et al., “The FAIR Guiding Principles,” Scientific Data (2016)
  • Susan Leigh Star and James Griesemer, “Institutional Ecology, ‘Translations’ and Boundary Objects,” Social Studies of Science (1989)
Research and mentoring
  • National Academies, The Science of Effective Mentorship in STEMM (2019)
  • National Academies, Enhancing the Effectiveness of Team Science (2015)
  • Monica Higgins and Kathy Kram, “Reconceptualizing Mentoring at Work: A Developmental Network Perspective,” Academy of Management Review (2001)
  • Vertically Integrated Projects (VIP) Consortium
  • Lisa Auchincloss et al., “Assessment of Course-Based Undergraduate Research Experiences,” CBE—Life Sciences Education (2014)
  • Ferric Fang and Arturo Casadevall, “Research Funding: the Case for a Modified Lottery,” mBio (2016)
AI and assessment
  • Ethan Mollick and Lilach Mollick, “Assigning AI: Seven Approaches for Students” (2023)
  • Mike Perkins et al., the AI Assessment Scale (2024)
  • UNESCO, Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research (2023)
Land, elders, and knowledge
  • Robin Wall Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass (2013)
  • Theophrastus, Enquiry into Plants (c. 300 BCE)
↑ Back to the outlineMap

The network

The people, organizations, books, and hubs this project draws on, in three dimensions.

This project as a hub

The network this project joins

Grouped by self-knowledge, praxis, universality, open access, and knowledge hubs. Lines show documented relationships only.

Works best on a computer screen. On a phone, tap a spoke and then tap names to explore, swipe sideways to turn the network, and pinch to zoom.

Explore projects

Start with the projects by songbird-soundscape, then follow their links outward.

Layers
Key: colors, shapes, and lines
Self-knowledge Praxis Universality Open access Knowledge hub Bold name = has a website Person School, program, or institution Book
Worked together directly Met, corresponded, or shared an institution Built on or responded to the other's ideas What a hub draws on Hubs participate in universality (stronger as they reach more spokes)

Organizations and knowledge hubs show first. Switch on Thinkers to see where people like John Dewey fit, and Books for their works. Drag to turn the network in 3D. Click the map, then scroll or pinch to zoom, or use the buttons. Select anyone to see who they are and how they connect. This is a first shell, not a complete map, and it grows as people add to it.

Joining the commons

Participating nodes

Projects, labs, and communities that have joined the Open Commons of Learning. Each keeps its own work and its own home, and connects to the rest through shared themes. One is shown below, picked at random each visit.

All participating nodes (0)

    Want your project or lab to join? Start a thread in Discussions.

    ↑ Back to the outlineA personal note

    Ethical statement

    The costs of the tools behind this work, and why I use them anyway.

    The costs

    What these tools cost

    This statement represents my personal perspective, which I do not expect or require anyone to adopt for themselves.

    The tools I use to build this work have a destructive side:

    Water

    Data centers use large amounts of water for cooling, and in dry regions they can draw down the local groundwater supply.

    Mining

    Rare earth elements, cobalt, lithium, copper, and tantalum are dug from landscapes at real cost to ecosystems, and too often to the people who mine them, sometimes including children.

    Energy

    Training and running AI, and powering every device, still depends heavily on electricity from fossil fuels.

    Manufacturing

    Making chips consumes huge amounts of energy and ultrapure water, and releases fluorinated gases such as nitrogen trifluoride and sulfur hexafluoride, which trap thousands of times more heat than carbon dioxide and can persist for centuries to millennia.

    Electronic waste

    Devices become obsolete and are quickly replaced. Much of the waste from this turnover is shipped abroad and taken apart by hand, exposing workers to toxic metals.

    Hidden labor

    AI systems rely on low-paid workers who label data and filter out disturbing content, often in the Global South.

    Other people's work

    These models were trained on writing, art, and research made by people who were rarely asked and seldom paid.

    Noise

    Data centers run cooling fans and backup generators around the clock. People living nearby describe a constant hum that disrupts sleep and daily life.

    Local communities

    New data centers claim land and strain power grids, which can raise electricity costs for the people living nearby.

    Most of these costs fall on people and places far from me, who did not choose them. No personal choice settles that. The real answers are collective: fair pay and safe conditions for the people who mine, build and label; consent and payment for the people whose work trains these models; and limits on the water and energy that data centers draw.

    It would be hypocritical to ask others to give these tools up while I continue to use them. Whether or not these means are justified rests on the ends that I hope they facilitate:

    1. the collective ownership of freely shared information, and
    2. the collaborative creation of high-quality educational resources that help people understand ecosystem function, organismal biology, human ecology, and climate processes.

    Part of my reason for creating this work and sharing it openly is to avoid doubling efforts that make use of these tools. When knowledge is shared, the cost of building it is paid once instead of over and over.

    When I looked, there did not appear to be a non-commercialized searchable network of people, organizations, teaching tools, and philosophical dispositions so as to facilitate connection based on curiosity, purpose, and study subject.

    If you know of work like this, please connect. I would much rather join forces than duplicate.

    Sources

    ↑ Back to the outlineJoin in

    Get together

    An open invitation to join a network of scholars and knowledge hubs.

    Everyone is welcome

    Join the network

    Scholars, students, educators, elders, and anyone who's curious: bring what you know. Make a hub, join a hub, or link your lab.

    This network is being built carefully, so that it doesn't turn into social media as we've come to know it. It's built for exploring a network of knowledge, not scrolling a feed.

    What you'll find
    • Network exploration: follow the links between hubs, fields, and the people doing the work
    • Open information, free for anyone to read
    • Open-source code that anyone can inspect, copy, and improve
    • Hubs linked across people, fields of study, and institutions
    • Contributions reviewed before they appear, so the network is safe for everyone
    • News and updates posted on the main forum
    What you won't find
    • Passwords or log-ins
    • Ads
    • System emails
    • Status updates
    • Likes
    • Follower counts
    • Addictive scrolling environments
    Ways to take part

    Where to start

    News and updates

    There are no newsletters or system emails. Check the main forum for news and updates. The forum is coming soon.

    ↑ Back to the outlineContact and join

    About this project

    Who's behind it, how to reach out, and how to join.

    Who we are

    An open framework, still growing

    The Open Commons of Learning is a working framework for teaching, education, and research. Its site administrator is songbird-soundscape. It is meant to be shared, questioned, and built on by anyone who cares about learning.

    Get in touch

    Reach out for discussion

    News and updates will be posted in the project's forum on GitHub Discussions. There are no newsletters or system emails.

    Join in

    Ways to take part

    • Make a hub for a question in your field.
    • Join a hub and help review and improve it.
    • Link your lab, field station, museum, or program to the network.
    • Share what you know, especially if you're a senior scholar or practitioner.
    • Offer hosting, which the network still needs.
    See how to get together →
    Open by design

    Free to use, copy, and improve

    The text and design are licensed under CC BY 4.0: share and adapt freely, with credit. All the files are on GitHub: open-commons and drifting-through-deep-time.

    Parts of this site were drafted with the help of AI, so errors are possible. Corrections are welcome, and finding them is part of how this project teaches.

    🚧 Under construction